PostgreSQL 10 logical replication only synchronizing one time and then stopping

I have one database containing user information that I’m replicating to a separate application db on the same cluster. After an error I discarded the subscription, replication slot, and the replicated schema. After re-creating the tables and subscription the data replicated as expected. However, all subsequent changes after the initial load failed to synchronize. This included all major operation INSERT, UPDATE, & DELETE.